open import Cat.Diagram.Pullback
open import Cat.Prelude

import Cat.Reasoning

module Cat.Diagram.Pullback.Properties where

module _ {o ℓ} {C : Precategory o ℓ} where
  open Cat.Reasoning C
  open is-pullback
  
  private variable
    A B P : Ob
    f g h : Hom A B

Properties of pullbacks🔗

This module chronicles some general properties of pullbacks.

Pasting law🔗

The pasting law for pullbacks says that, if in the commutative diagram below the the right square is a pullback, then the left square is universal if, and only if, the outer rectangle is, too. Note the emphasis on the word commutative: if we don’t know that both squares (and the outer rectangle) all commute, the pasting law does not go through.

  module _ {a b c d e f : Ob}
           {a→d : Hom a d} {a→b : Hom a b} {b→c : Hom b c}
           {d→e : Hom d e} {b→e : Hom b e} {e→f : Hom e f}
           {c→f : Hom c f}
           (right-pullback : is-pullback C b→c c→f b→e e→f)
    where
  
    private module right = is-pullback right-pullback

Let’s start with proving that, if the outer rectangle is a pullback, then so is the left square. Assume, then, that we have some other object $x,$ which fits into a cone, like in the diagram below. I’ve coloured the two arrows we assume commutative.

    pasting-outer→left-is-pullback
      : is-pullback C (b→c ∘ a→b) c→f a→d (e→f ∘ d→e)
      → (square : b→e ∘ a→b ≡ d→e ∘ a→d)
      → is-pullback C a→b b→e a→d d→e
    pasting-outer→left-is-pullback outer square = pb where
      module outer = is-pullback outer

To appeal to the universal property of the outer pullback, we must somehow extend our red cone over $b \to e \leftarrow d$ to one over $c \to f \leftarrow e .$ Can we do this? Yes! By assumption, the square on the right commutes, which lets us apply commutativity of the red diagram (the assumption $p$ in the code). Check out the calculation below:

      abstract
        path : ∀ {P} {P→b : Hom P b} {P→d : Hom P d} (p : b→e ∘ P→b ≡ d→e ∘ P→d)
             → c→f ∘ b→c ∘ P→b ≡ (e→f ∘ d→e) ∘ P→d
        path {_} {P→b} {P→d} p =
          c→f ∘ b→c ∘ P→b   ≡⟨ extendl right.square ⟩≡
          e→f ∘ b→e ∘ P→b   ≡⟨ ap (e→f ∘_) p ⟩≡
          e→f ∘ d→e ∘ P→d   ≡⟨ cat! C ⟩≡
          (e→f ∘ d→e) ∘ P→d ∎
  
      pb : is-pullback C _ _ _ _
      pb .is-pullback.square =
        b→e ∘ a→b ≡⟨ square ⟩≡
        d→e ∘ a→d ∎

We thus have an induced map $x \to a,$ which, since $a$ is a pullback, makes everything in sight commute, and does so uniquely.

      pb .universal {p₁' = P→b} {p₂' = P→d} p =
        outer.universal {p₁' = b→c ∘ P→b} {p₂' = P→d} (path p)
  
      pb .p₁∘universal {p₁' = P→b} {p₂' = P→d} {p = p} =
        right.unique₂ {p = pulll right.square ∙ pullr p}
          (assoc _ _ _ ∙ outer.p₁∘universal)
          (pulll square ∙ pullr outer.p₂∘universal)
          refl p
  
      pb .p₂∘universal {p₁' = P→b} {p₂' = P→d} {p = p} = outer.p₂∘universal
  
      pb .unique {p = p} q r =
        outer.unique (sym (ap (_ ∘_) (sym q) ∙ assoc _ _ _)) r

For the converse, suppose that both small squares are a pullback, and we have a cone over $c \to f \leftarrow d .$ By the universal property of the right pullback, we can find a map $x \to b$ forming the left leg of a cone over $b \to e \leftarrow d;$ By the universal property of the left square, we then have a map $x \to a,$ as we wanted.

    pasting-left→outer-is-pullback
      : is-pullback C a→b b→e a→d d→e
      → (square : c→f ∘ b→c ∘ a→b ≡ (e→f ∘ d→e) ∘ a→d)
      → is-pullback C (b→c ∘ a→b) c→f a→d (e→f ∘ d→e)
    pasting-left→outer-is-pullback left square = pb where
      module left = is-pullback left
  
      pb : is-pullback C (b→c ∘ a→b) c→f a→d (e→f ∘ d→e)
      pb .is-pullback.square =
        c→f ∘ b→c ∘ a→b   ≡⟨ square ⟩≡
        (e→f ∘ d→e) ∘ a→d ∎
      pb .universal {p₁' = P→c} {p₂' = P→d} x =
        left.universal {p₁' = right.universal (x ∙ sym (assoc _ _ _))} {p₂' = P→d}
          right.p₂∘universal
      pb .p₁∘universal = pullr left.p₁∘universal ∙ right.p₁∘universal
      pb .p₂∘universal = left.p₂∘universal
      pb .unique {p₁' = P→c} {P→d} {p = p} {lim'} q r =
        left.unique (right.unique (assoc _ _ _ ∙ q) s) r
        where
          s : b→e ∘ a→b ∘ lim' ≡ d→e ∘ P→d
          s =
            b→e ∘ a→b ∘ lim'   ≡⟨ pulll left.square ⟩≡
            (d→e ∘ a→d) ∘ lim' ≡⟨ pullr r ⟩≡
            d→e ∘ P→d          ∎

Monomorphisms🔗

Being a monomorphism is a “limit property”. Specifically, $f : A \to B$ is a monomorphism iff. the square below is a pullback.

  module _ {a b} {f : Hom a b} where
    is-monic→is-pullback : is-monic f → is-pullback C id f id f
    is-monic→is-pullback mono .square = refl
    is-monic→is-pullback mono .universal {p₁' = p₁'} p = p₁'
    is-monic→is-pullback mono .p₁∘universal = idl _
    is-monic→is-pullback mono .p₂∘universal {p = p} = idl _ ∙ mono _ _ p
    is-monic→is-pullback mono .unique p q = introl refl ∙ p
  
    is-pullback→is-monic : is-pullback C id f id f → is-monic f
    is-pullback→is-monic pb f g p = sym (pb .p₁∘universal {p = p}) ∙ pb .p₂∘universal

Pullbacks additionally preserve monomorphisms, as shown below:

  is-monic→pullback-is-monic
    : ∀ {x y z} {f : Hom x z} {g : Hom y z} {p} {p1 : Hom p x} {p2 : Hom p y}
    → is-monic f
    → is-pullback C p1 f p2 g
    → is-monic p2
  is-monic→pullback-is-monic {f = f} {g} {p1 = p1} {p2} mono pb h j p = eq
    where
      module pb = is-pullback pb
      q : f ∘ p1 ∘ h ≡ f ∘ p1 ∘ j
      q =
        f ∘ p1 ∘ h ≡⟨ extendl pb.square ⟩≡
        g ∘ p2 ∘ h ≡⟨ ap (g ∘_) p ⟩≡
        g ∘ p2 ∘ j ≡˘⟨ extendl pb.square ⟩≡˘
        f ∘ p1 ∘ j ∎
  
      r : p1 ∘ h ≡ p1 ∘ j
      r = mono _ _ q
  
      eq : h ≡ j
      eq = pb.unique₂ {p = extendl pb.square} r p refl refl

  rotate-pullback
    : ∀ {x y z} {f : Hom x z} {g : Hom y z} {p} {p1 : Hom p x} {p2 : Hom p y}
    → is-pullback C p1 f p2 g
    → is-pullback C p2 g p1 f
  rotate-pullback pb .square = sym (pb .square)
  rotate-pullback pb .universal p = pb .universal (sym p)
  rotate-pullback pb .p₁∘universal = pb .p₂∘universal
  rotate-pullback pb .p₂∘universal = pb .p₁∘universal
  rotate-pullback pb .unique p q = pb .unique q p
  
  is-pullback-iso
    : ∀ {p p' x y z} {f : Hom x z} {g : Hom y z} {p1 : Hom p x} {p2 : Hom p y}
    → (i : p ≅ p')
    → is-pullback C p1 f p2 g
    → is-pullback C (p1 ∘ _≅_.from i) f (p2 ∘ _≅_.from i) g
  is-pullback-iso {f = f} {g} {p1} {p2} i pb = pb' where
    module i = _≅_ i
    pb' : is-pullback C _ _ _ _
    pb' .square = extendl (pb .square)
    pb' .universal p = i.to ∘ pb .universal p
    pb' .p₁∘universal = cancel-inner i.invr ∙ pb .p₁∘universal
    pb' .p₂∘universal = cancel-inner i.invr ∙ pb .p₂∘universal
    pb' .unique p q = invertible→monic (iso→invertible (i Iso⁻¹)) _ _ $ sym $
      cancell i.invr ∙ sym (pb .unique (assoc _ _ _ ∙ p) (assoc _ _ _ ∙ q))
  
  pullback-unique
    : ∀ {p p' x y z} {f : Hom x z} {g : Hom y z} {p1 : Hom p x} {p2 : Hom p y}
        {p1' : Hom p' x} {p2' : Hom p' y}
    → is-pullback C p1 f p2 g
    → is-pullback C p1' f p2' g
    → p ≅ p'
  pullback-unique {f = f} {g} {p1} {p2} {p1'} {p2'} pb pb'
    = make-iso pb→pb' pb'→pb il ir
    where
      pb→pb' = pb' .universal (pb .square)
      pb'→pb = pb .universal (pb' .square)
      il = unique₂ pb' {p = pb' .square}
        (pulll (pb' .p₁∘universal) ∙ pb .p₁∘universal)
        (pulll (pb' .p₂∘universal) ∙ pb .p₂∘universal)
        (idr _) (idr _)
      ir = unique₂ pb {p = pb .square}
        (pulll (pb .p₁∘universal) ∙ pb' .p₁∘universal)
        (pulll (pb .p₂∘universal) ∙ pb' .p₂∘universal)
        (idr _) (idr _)
  
  Pullback-unique
    : ∀ {x y z} {f : Hom x z} {g : Hom y z}
    → is-category C
    → is-prop (Pullback C f g)
  Pullback-unique {x = X} {Y} {Z} {f} {g} c-cat x y = p where
    open Pullback
    module x = Pullback x
    module y = Pullback y
    apices = c-cat .to-path (pullback-unique (x .has-is-pb) (y .has-is-pb))
  
    abstract
      p1s : PathP (λ i → Hom (apices i) X) x.p₁ y.p₁
      p1s = Univalent.Hom-pathp-refll-iso c-cat (x.p₁∘universal)
  
      p2s : PathP (λ i → Hom (apices i) Y) x.p₂ y.p₂
      p2s = Univalent.Hom-pathp-refll-iso c-cat (x.p₂∘universal)
  
      lims
        : ∀ {P'} {p1' : Hom P' X} {p2' : Hom P' Y} (p : f ∘ p1' ≡ g ∘ p2')
        → PathP (λ i → Hom P' (apices i)) (x.universal p) (y.universal p)
      lims p = Univalent.Hom-pathp-reflr-iso c-cat $
        y.unique (pulll y.p₁∘universal ∙ x.p₁∘universal)
                (pulll y.p₂∘universal ∙ x.p₂∘universal)
  
    p : x ≡ y
    p i .apex = apices i
    p i .p₁ = p1s i
    p i .p₂ = p2s i
    p i .has-is-pb .square =
      is-prop→pathp (λ i → Hom-set (apices i) Z (f ∘ p1s i) (g ∘ p2s i))
        x.square y.square i
    p i .has-is-pb .universal p = lims p i
    p i .has-is-pb .p₁∘universal {p = p} =
      is-prop→pathp (λ i → Hom-set _ X (p1s i ∘ lims p i) _)
        x.p₁∘universal y.p₁∘universal i
    p i .has-is-pb .p₂∘universal {p = p} =
      is-prop→pathp (λ i → Hom-set _ _ (p2s i ∘ lims p i) _)
        x.p₂∘universal y.p₂∘universal i
    p i .has-is-pb .unique {P' = P'} {p₁' = p₁'} {p₂' = p₂'} {p = p'} {lim' = lim'} =
      is-prop→pathp
        (λ i   → Π-is-hlevel {A = Hom P' (apices i)} 1
         λ lim → Π-is-hlevel {A = p1s i ∘ lim ≡ p₁'} 1
         λ p   → Π-is-hlevel {A = p2s i ∘ lim ≡ p₂'} 1
         λ q   → Hom-set P' (apices i) lim (lims p' i))
        (λ lim → x.unique {lim' = lim})
        (λ lim → y.unique {lim' = lim})
        i lim'
  
  canonically-stable
    : ∀ {ℓ'} (P : ∀ {a b} → Hom a b → Type ℓ')
    → is-category C
    → (pb : ∀ {a b c} (f : Hom a c) (g : Hom b c) → Pullback C f g)
    → ( ∀ {A B X} (f : Hom A B) (g : Hom X B)
      → P f → P (pb g f .Pullback.p₁) )
    → is-pullback-stable C P
  canonically-stable P C-cat pbs stab f g Pf pb =
    transport (λ i → P (Pullback-unique C-cat (pbs g f) pb' i .Pullback.p₁))
      (stab f g Pf)
    where
      pb' : Pullback C _ _
      pb' = record { has-is-pb = pb }